The Sugar Quill
Author: Potioncat  Story: The Best House at Hogwarts  Chapter: Default
The distribution of this story is for personal use only. Any other form of distribution is prohibited without the consent of the author.

The Best House at Hogwarts

The Best House at Hogwarts



Theodore Nott gave his father a brave smile and boarded the train. The crush of people on the platform had made him uncomfortable, but it was nothing to the way he felt on the train itself.  It was full of students, chattering and laughing, meeting friends, making friends.   He knew a few neighbors from Diagon Alley, but he had to no desire to tag along like a little kid. He just wanted to find a quiet spot and sit out of the way. 


Already compartments were filling up.  Theo felt his throat tighten.  What he wanted to do was bolt.  Not back to home so much as away from this mass of people. He’d have to look for a group of new students or find Malfoy.  But he knew he’d rather endure meeting new people than endure Draco.  He moved down the aisle, trying to avoid bumping older students, as he glanced through doors.


He found a bunch of students who appeared his age and, taking a deep breath said, “Hello. First year here. Do you have room? They all made welcoming noises. He hefted his trunk to a storage rack and moved into the group.


Names were tossed out so fast he couldn’t catch them all.  But he was relieved that no one seemed to know each other. Every few moments someone stood to lean at the window and wave. Theo glanced out once, but he was certain his father had left as soon as he got on the train. There was a long whistle, a call from the conductor and the train started with a lurch. 


For a few moments there was silence, broken slightly by uncomfortable shifting and hard swallows. And at last one of the girls spoke a little too loudly, “What Houses do you think you’ll be sorted into?”


“Gryffindor!  Least Me Mum thinks so.  She says anyone as reckless as I am couldn’t go anywhere else.” A boy with an Irish brogue said, grinning..


“Gryffindors are brave,” the girl corrected.  “I’ve read about the Houses in Hogwarts A History.  I think Gryffindor must be the best House.” Theo hadn’t heard her name at all, and couldn’t guess what it might be. Although everyone else in the compartment was wearing regular clothes, very Muggle suitable, she was already in her school robes. Her hair was wild and frizzy and in his mind Theo was calling her “Frizz.”


Two voices protested together, “The best House is Slytherin.”

                                                   “The best House is Ravenclaw.”


 “Slytherin is known for helping its students succeed after school. A lot have become important leaders and famous Healers.”  The speaker was a dark haired girl who seemed to think she had already been sorted into Slytherin.


The Irish boy interrupted, “Yeah, but most Dark Wizards come from Slytherin!”


“Well, that might be true, but, Gryffindor has its share of bad wizards too,” she argued back.



“Ravenclaw is famous for clever wizards, the ones who come up with new spells and new magic. That’s where I want to go!”  the boy called Shue…no Boot…piped in.


“Yes, Ravenclaw would be a good house,” Frizz said.


“I think so too,” Theo said suddenly and then realized everyone was looking at him as if he wanted to go there because the girl had said so.  He turned red and added, “but Slytherin would be a good House. A lot of my family has been in Slytherin.”


Frizz seemed to be appraising both him and the dark haired girl.  Theo went on, “Slytherin has a mixed reputation.”   He realized he sounded like his father now.  “My Dad says some families are jealous of Slytherin and a little afraid of it but that’s because it’s full of strong wizards.”


“Slytherin and Gryffindor both sound scary,” Susan Bones said, “You’re right about Gryffindors being reckless, Seamus.” She looked at Irish boy and Theo silently repeated his name to himself as she continued, “My Gram says Gryffindors are famous for being brave, but they don’t always think. She says, “Gryffindors rush in where Ravenclaws fear to tread.”


“Ravenclaws aren’t cowards!” Boot protested.


“Well, no. But they’re famous for learning and for knowing what they are getting into.”  Susan continued, “Ravenclaw would be a good House, but I’m hoping for Hufflepuff.”


“Hufflepuff! Who would want…oh, sorry,” Seamus started.


“It’s a good House…the backbone of the wizarding world! Lots of good strong witches have come from Hufflepuff. My Gram did,” Susan said firmly.


Mandy-- or was it Candy?—joined in. “It isn’t supposed to matter anyway. Not really. My Dad says no one cares once you’re out of school. He’s always saying, ‘Don’t look at the House the wizard goes into, but at the wizard that comes out.’


Frizz spoke, “But Slytherin doesn’t take Muggle-born students, does it?”


“No, why should it? They wouldn’t be able to keep up, would they?” Dark Hair answered.  Theo wished he could remember her name. 


“Me Dad’s a Muggle. Nothing wrong with it!” Seamus snapped.


“He doesn’t do magic, does he? There’s no reason to put Muggle-borns with Purebloods.  It would hold the Purebloods back! If Muggle-borns have to come to Hogwarts they should go to Hufflepuff. Hufflepuff takes anyone.”


“I’m Muggle-born and I don’t think I’d hold anyone back!” Frizz said, her eyes flashing.  Seamus, red with anger, glared silently and Susan Bones looked about to burst.


“Yes, I thought you might be.” Dark Hair said smugly. She tossed her head and looked out the window.


“I think I’ll go explore the train!” Frizz announced and turned to leave.


Seamus and Susan followed after without a word.


There was a very awkward silence. Theo cleared his throat. “My Dad knows Professor Snape, the Head of Slytherin House. He came to dinner one night. He said that he’s seen weak Pureblood wizards and strong Muggle-born ones.” 


“And what did he say about mixing them?” Dark Hair asked.


“Nothing. He said Hogwarts accepts every magic child and teaches every magic child.  He says it’s Dumbledore’s policy.”


“So you already have an in for Slytherin?” Dark Hair asked, changing the direction of the conversation.


“No. He said the Sorting Hat decides and that it’s final.”


“Did he say where he thought you’d go?”


Theo shook his head, “He said where ever I was sorted, I should look like I wanted to go there. ‘Your Housemates will be watching,’ he said.” Theo felt foolish now. It probably looked like he was showing off. 


The conversation stalled and Theo recalled the evening Professor Snape had visited.

Having a guest for dinner had been a surprise to him. Not only for dinner, but at their home for dinner. He and his father usually ate at one of the taverns on Diagon Alley. Theo hadn’t understood at first, but his father had invited the professor just to introduce them. And when it had become obvious, Theo had been embarrassed.


They had talked about the Houses that night. After admitting he was biased, the professor had said, “The biggest problem with Slytherin is that some students confuse marks with knowledge. Those students go to great length to get high marks, but forget to learn the material. However, those who are truly interested in learning the magic do exceptionally well.  There is no stopping a Slytherin who has a goal.”


“What about Ravenclaw?” Theo asked. He wished he hadn’t. Snape looked at him with beady eyes for several moments. It must have been clear that Ravenclaw was Theo’s first choice.


“Ravenclaws love knowledge for knowledge’s sake. Some forget to use it. But, as a group, they are very clever.”


His father had almost demanded that the professor tell him if he thought Theo would get into Slytherin. Somehow the professor skirted the issue, never saying anything really bad about any House and at last had snapped, “He’ll be the same boy after he’s sorted that he was before.”


For some reason, the Professor immediately turned to Theo and asked, “Which House do you want?”


It had come so unexpectantly that Theo just stared for a moment, stammered, then said with confidence, “Whichever House the Sorting Hat says, of course.” 


The professor had given him the slightest of smiles and seemed satisfied. Theo thought that it would be interesting having Professor Snape as a Head, but a little frightening too.


Later he had complained to his father about setting him up. But the senior Nott had merely shrugged. “If you don’t end up in his House, at least he’ll recognize you when you come to Potions. You might be happy he came tonight. I’ve heard he can be pretty hard on the non-Slytherin students.”


“Theo looks like he’s taken a forgetfulness potion!” Mandy laughed gently.  Theo looked up, realizing his mind had wandered. He smiled and shrugged.


Someone brought out a pack of exploding snap cards. A few pulled out books. Theo reached for his book but was interrupted as several boys stopped and looked in. He recognized Malfoy, but not the two husky boys that flanked him.


 “Oh, hello, Nott.”  Draco looked around the compartment.  “I thought I’d get a group together who expect to land in Slytherin.”


Dark Hair jumped up with a smile and crossed to the door. “I’m going to be in Slytherin!  I just have to be! I’m Pansy Parkinson.”


Malfoy studied her moment, then nodded. “ Draco Malfoy. This is Crabbe. Over here is Goyle.” He looked at Theo, “Coming, Nott?” 


Theo swallowed. “No thanks, Malfoy.”


“Think you might not make it?  Maybe you aren’t good enough,” Malfoy turned abruptly and strode away.  Pansy glanced back with a smirk and followed after. There was another long silence. Theo thought to himself that Ravenclaw was looking better and better.


The afternoon dragged on. Some of the others went exploring.  A couple of new kids came in. Mostly Theo read his book. Finally someone called out to change and suddenly they were in Hogsmeade.


At last Theo stood with the crowd of first years and stared around at the Great Hall.  Nothing had prepared him for this. He glanced toward Frizz, and to his surprise she seemed less excited about it than most others. The stern witch whose name he’d already forgotten began calling names in alphabetical order.  N was a long way off.


He scanned the staff table and saw Professor Snape. Their eyes met briefly, but the man gave no sign of recognition. Theo forgot completely that the professor had seemed interesting and instead remembered now how cold he had been. Now he looked absolutely scary. 


“Ravenclaw,” Theo said softly.  As his name grew closer, Theo’s throat grew dry. Silently he was chanting “Ravenclaw, Ravenclaw.”  And at last his name was called and his brain went as dry as his mouth.


There was a blur then silence as the hat dropped on his head, “Ravenclaw?” a new voice asked. “Yes, you would fit nicely in Ravenclaw.” Theo started to stand, but realized the hat was still speaking. “You aren’t the first Slytherin to want Ravenclaw. Very similar the two.  But for you…SLYTHERIN!”


Theo forced himself to smile and hurried away from the stool in the only direction he could go-- the Slytherin table.  Malfoy was sneering, “Well, joining us after all?”


“Yes,” Theo said brusquely, shaking the hands of the older Slytherins and nodding at the other first years. A new name was called, “Parkinson, Pansy.” 


Theo groaned silently and pretended to welcome her to the table.  Harry Potter was called and the sound in the room became a roar. Theo looked over in surprise. The boy with the famous scar was going to be a classmate!  He watched Potter as he moved to the Gryffindor table and sat beside Frizz.


Finally Zabini was called and became a Slytherin. “I don’t believe he made it!” Draco muttered. Zabini came quickly, looking a little bewildered and Theo motioned to the empty spot beside him.  If Draco didn’t like him, there was a good chance Theo would.


They listened to the Headmaster’s strange speech. Malfoy made several disapproving noises that entertained most of the others. Theo thought that Professor Snape had seemed to respect Dumbledore, although he hadn’t really said so. He kept his opinion to himself but studied the old wizard as he spoke. The food appeared and Theo forgot to worry about Housemates and Headmasters.


After a few mouthfuls, he looked up to the Staff table and saw Professor Snape was looking at their table. Theo watched as the professor’s eyes snapped from one new Slytherin to the other, as if he were analyzing potions. Their eyes met and this time the Professor nodded.  For some reason, Theo found himself smiling back. The professor’s expression didn’t change, but he looked at Theo for a moment before moving his gaze to the Gryffindor table. Theo decided that whether he liked it or not, he was Slytherin. And for the next 7 years Slytherin was the best House at Hogwarts.



Write a review! PLEASE NOTE: The purpose of reviewing a story or piece of art at the Sugar Quill is to provide comments that will be useful to the author/artist. We encourage you to put a bit of thought into your review before posting. Please be thoughtful and considerate, even if you have legitimate criticism of a story or artwork. (You may click here to read other reviews of this work).
* = Required fields
*Sugar Quill Forums username:
*Sugar Quill Forums password:
If you do not have a Sugar Quill Forums username, please register. Bear in mind that it may take up to 72 hours for your account to be approved. Thank you for your patience!
The Sugar Quill was created by Zsenya and Arabella. For questions, please send us an Owl!

-- Powered by SQ3 : Coded by David : Design by James --