The Sugar Quill
Author: prplhez8  Story: Sincerely, Albus Dumbledore  Chapter: Default
The distribution of this story is for personal use only. Any other form of distribution is prohibited without the consent of the author.

Dearest Harry,



A/N: This was written as a birthday present to St. Margaret’s.   A group of writers that habit the fluffy thread took a task (Write a letter to Harry on his seventeenth birthday about love from a canon character of your choice) and it became a huge surprise birthday present to our fearless leader, St. Margaret’s.  Here’s my contribution:





I am hoping this letter finds you well.  Seventeen years old.  How does it feel?  It was many years ago that I was seventeen, but I’ve not forgotten the wonders of my youth.  Ah, youth. It seems, at the time, that those days would never pass.  That we are mired down in the day to day of living, but you will soon find that time passes quickly – the pages of your history will fly by.  Oh dear, forgive my ramblings, Harry.  There are so many things I wish to tell you, but alas, my younger years are not the particular correspondence for this time. 


Love is what I want to talk to you about today, Harry.   To convey an old man’s lessons to a young man’s heart.  In your short life, you have been so harshly robbed of things that are near and dear to you – and yet you have persevered - but I wonder, with all these losses if anyone could ever impart to you the lessons in loving open and wholeheartedly?  I hope you will hear what I am trying to tell you, Harry.  As a young man, I acted foolishly in many a situation when it came to matters of the heart.  Of particular note, I acted out in anger at a refusal to a proposal, and I lost her forever.  You may ask yourself why I was alone all of these years.  I’ve asked myself that question many a time.  Pride, Harry, pride is a dangerous emotion.  Don’t let it rule you. The earnest need to heed the call of those around you, to protect, to defend what is dearest to us is a noble aspiration, but when it becomes all that you know, it will be a cold comfort. Again, I believe I’ll leave that tale to another time. 


In all my years, I have come across so many versions of love.  Pure and passionate as Lily and James Potter, warm and welcoming as Arthur and Molly Weasley, dark and disturbing as Merope and ….  But the love that struck me most, and has stayed with me year after year, was a love between a parent and a child.   Sit with me as I tell you this story, Harry.   Hear of your first days on this earth.


I walked into the door of the small cottage with a soft swish of my robes.  The unbearable heat wave that had struck the United Kingdom was left on the doorstep as the inside of the minute abode had been magically cooled. 


“Professor Dumbledore.” I was greeted with a handshake and a smile by Sirius Black and Remus Lupin.


“I hear congratulations are in order.  We have a new member of the Potter family.” Greeting this makeshift family, I handed over a package of cigars to the two young men who greeted me.


James Potter strolled out of a doorway to the left and gave a small tired smile.  “Come in, Professor.  Come see him.”


Walking into the bedroom, I found the proud mother sitting in a rocker with a small swaddled bundle in her arms.   She stood even as I bade her sit. 


“Sit and hold him, Professor.”


“Oh, I couldn’t possibly.  I have twitchy limbs, the folly of being old, you know.”


But with the pleading look from the young parent’s eyes imploring me, I sat.  Accepting the small bundle, I looked at the black hair sticking in all directions.  Looking at James, I gave a small huff of laughter.  “It would seem, Mr. Potter, that young Harry has your hair.”


Remus Lupin and Sirius Black stood at the threshold watching the tableau in front of them, shadowed by Peter Pettigrew.  Muted snickers soon filled the room as we discussed poor Harry’s plight of having his fathers’ hair.  I watched as Lily, reverently, touched her son’s unruly hair.  And she whispered, so softly:


 “I wouldn’t change a thing.  Not a thing.”


Wetness blurred my vision for a moment.


“Our differences are what make us unique, Mrs. Potter.  It is good to note that your son will be loved, it is a wonderful legacy to leave our children.”


She looked at me with those green eyes.   I shall never forget that look she gave me.


“Yes, well, Professor, you gave us a grand example.  We are, after all, your legacy of love.”  She then stroked Harry’s pink cheek.  “And he is our legacy.”     



Do you see, Harry?  All of this love, and even from Peter.  I believe at one time, he might have even cared for you.  I’m sure this is the hardest bit to see.  Recognizing evil and betrayal will always be the hardest to identify, especially concerning those we choose to trust with things that are dearest to us.  I dearly hope that you will never know this degree of betrayal.   Even when we are aware, life will spring unpleasant elements into our lives.  It is up to each of us to determine what we are to do with the strife that we are afflicted with.  The moment I shared with you is a great tool for you to draw upon, Harry.  When your parents were surrounded by death, grief and fear they chose to believe in their love. 


You have been surrounded by so much love at all times in your life.  It may not have been evident, but as you know, you were protected by your mother’s love.  And when you became eleven and eligible for attendance to Hogwarts, you were soon surrounded by another kind of love.  Friends.  I could tell you of how the older Gryffindors looked out for you even during moments that you were not present.  Fred and George Weasley were mainly responsible for many attacks upon … Well, again, a subject better left for another time - let us say, that you were well looked after.  Picking friends for you was something I was prepared to do, believe it or not.  Although I do not think I could have found two truer companions for you than Ron Weasley and Hermione Granger. 


I know that during your years of friendship there have been so many trials and tribulations for you, and yet you persevered, your trio has been unbroken. Ron and Hermione have given you loyalty, courage and a willingness to risk themselves for you.  This will remain with you always.  I have no direct moment to share with you of your friendship with these two that would outdo the ones you have.  But it did my heart good to be able to look out the window of my office and see your dark hair crowded in with a bushy-haired little girl and a red headed young man. Yes, it did my heart good, as I imagine it helped yours, too.



Speaking of red hair, that brings to my last and maybe most important lesson.  Love, just love, Harry, is a hard thing to obtain.  I know you will continue to do what is right where the fight for our world is concerned.  But do not forget how your mother and father stood together in dire times – do not throw away what is most precious to you.   Here is my lesson to you, Harry.


Once upon a time there was a very powerful wizard who fell in love with a very powerful witch.  They had plans to marry, to have a family.  They would whisper late into the night of their dreams for their life.  Darkness soon spread over their world, like a storm stealing in through the guise of night.  The wizard knew he had to fight against this man, this evil.  But in doing so he turned away his true love, his soul, and his equal.  And in doing so, it would be his greatest regret, this life unlived with this woman. 


I will not be so boastful to say that I won wars, Harry.  Nor will I say that I was the greatest wizard of all time, I could list you many that were greater than I.  But I, too, have regrets, Harry.  Do not turn away from those who would love you, they could be your greatest accomplishments of all.


I will now put down my quill and wish you the happiest of birthdays, I am quite sure you will have many, many more.




Albus Dumbledore

Write a review! PLEASE NOTE: The purpose of reviewing a story or piece of art at the Sugar Quill is to provide comments that will be useful to the author/artist. We encourage you to put a bit of thought into your review before posting. Please be thoughtful and considerate, even if you have legitimate criticism of a story or artwork. (You may click here to read other reviews of this work).
* = Required fields
*Sugar Quill Forums username:
*Sugar Quill Forums password:
If you do not have a Sugar Quill Forums username, please register. Bear in mind that it may take up to 72 hours for your account to be approved. Thank you for your patience!
The Sugar Quill was created by Zsenya and Arabella. For questions, please send us an Owl!

-- Powered by SQ3 : Coded by David : Design by James --